A number of prestigious faculties of Delhi-NCR have allegedly held again college students in Lessons 6 and seven in violation of the Proper to Training Act of 2009, schooling activists and oldsters stated.
Training activists and oldsters have complained that many Delhi-NCR faculties are flouting the RTE Act by holding again college students in Lessons 6 and seven. (Praful Gangurde/HT Photograph)
The Division of College Training and Literacy beneath the Ministry of Training notified guidelines concerning ‘Examination and Holding Again in Sure Instances’ in December 2024 after the Proper to Training (RTE) Act 2009 was amended in 2019.
“The amended rules allow schools to detain students in Classes 5 and 8 only, that too after giving them additional opportunity for re-examination within two months from the date of declaration of results,” advocate and schooling activist Ashok Aggarwal advised PTI.
Additionally learn: NEET UG 2025: The best way to obtain admit playing cards when out? Listed here are steps that candidates ought to know
“Before the amendment, there was a no detention policy till Class 8. However, the government amended the Act and made a provision for detention at 5th and 8th grade. However, many private schools are dictating their terms to parents in violation of the Act.”
A number of dad and mom complained that faculties insist they both take a faculty leaving certificates or let the kid repeat the category within the sixth or seventh grade.
“My son is in Class 6 and we have been told that if he does not clear the re-exam scheduled in May, he will not be promoted to the next class. But norms say that students cannot be detained in classes other than 5 and 8. My son couldn’t score well due to bad health this year,” a dad or mum primarily based in Gurgaon stated on situation of anonymity.
Educationist Prof Anita Rampal, who was related to the School of Training in Delhi College, expressed shock on the blatant disregard for the Act by public faculties.
“If schools detain children in Classes 6 and 7, they are making a mockery of the RTE Act. I advise their parents to file complaints in the nearest district or session courts,” Prof Rampal stated.
Additionally learn: TS EAMCET Corridor Ticket 2025: When will TSCHE launch TG EAPCET Engineering corridor tickets?
“Schools must understand that the Act gives certain constitutional rights to children,” she added.
Ashok Ganguly, former chairman of Central Board of Secondary Training (CBSE), stated that neither the Proper to Training Act nor the Nationwide Training Coverage and the Nationwide Curriculum Framework permit any faculty to detain a scholar in Lessons 6 and seven.
Ganguly urged that even detaining college students in Lessons 5 and eight might be questioned at this stage because of the absence of laid-down procedures by the respective state authorities and schooling boards.
“So far as detention in Classes 5 and 8 is concerned, respective states or boards were supposed to issue necessary directions, and so far as I know, no state has done so,” Ganguly stated.
Part 16A of the RTE Act stipulates that there shall be common examinations in Lessons 5 and eight on the finish of each educational yr. “If a child fails to fulfil the promotion criteria, he shall be given additional opportunity for re-examination within two months from the date of declaration of results.”
The principles additional say that if the kid showing for re-examination fails to fulfil the promotion standards, he shall be held again in Class 5 or 8, because the case could also be.
“No child shall be expelled from any school till he completes elementary education,” the rule says.
In keeping with a doc uploaded on the web site of the Division of College Training and Literacy, compelling a baby to repeat a category is demotivating.
“Repeating a class does not give the child any special resources to deal with the same syllabus requirements for yet another year. Parents and friends of such children also tend to view them as being ‘fit for failure’, thereby reinforcing the school’s perception while declaring a child ‘fail’,” it stated.
“The ‘no detention’ provision in the RTE Act does not imply abandoning procedures that assess children’s learning. The RTE Act provides for putting in place a continuous and comprehensive evaluation procedure, a procedure that will be non-threatening, releases the child from fear and trauma of failure and enables the teacher to pay individual attention to the child’s learning and performance,” the doc added.
Requested in regards to the delay in notification for the reason that modification was authorized in 2019, Ministry of Training officers defined that the brand new Nationwide Training Coverage was introduced inside six months of the modification.